Why are there no women cartoonists? by Cinders McLeod

WebFind: “Why Are There No Women Cartoonists?” by Cinders McLeod

Why are there no women cartoonists? by Cinders McLeodCinders McLeod – writer, satirist, artist, doublebassist and creator of the Moneybunnies series, financial literary for kids – drew a cartoon in 1991 in response to the oft-asked question “why are there no women cartoonists?”

20 year later, in 2011, she looked at it and thought it should be out there and posted it on YouTube. “Some things have changed. A lot hasn’t. and it’s not just women cartoonists I’m talking about”, she notes.

My thanks to cartoonist Lorna Miller for the lead on this during discussion on Twitter about the lack of female political cartoonists in British newspapers, who also asked if any research has been done on employment rates within the industry. As Sandra Marrs of Metaphrog noted in the thread, “Very few make a living making comics, period, let alone women. But would be interesting to know the numbers,” so hopefully this is something others drawn into the chat – Laydeez Do Comics founder Nicola Streeten and Comics Laureate Hannah Berry among them – has joined the discussion, as Lorna notes her appalling treatment by one magazine she had worked for.

“I was dropped after 15 years digital colourist on well known kids mag,” she says. “New editor used recession cut backs as excuse, handed over some of my work to his mates, who copied the colour schemes I’d created, the rest became the artist’s job (for no extra pay).”

The discussion wasn’t totally gloomy – the work of ELCAF, the Lakes International Comc Art Festival and Thought Bubble promoting women creators was noted, as was the presence of The Laydeez Do Comics Graphic Novel Competition for long form comics, and the work of publishers such as Myriad Editions and Unbound promoting the work of women creators. Not to mention exhibitions of work, such as the Posy Simmonds exhibition currently running at House of Illustration. (The work of Broken Frontier should be noted, too).

It was generally agreed that while progress has been made, there’s still much to be done. [There are] lots of women in comics now,” noted Metaphrog’s Sandra Marrs,” and it’s changed the types of comics that are out there. We were around 20 years ago with you too, and the comic scene now is massively different. Back then as a woman in comics I felt like the odd one out.”

Speaking personally, I was also grateful to find out about Cinders animated film and be reminded of the work of the cartons of Martha “Marf” Richler, as well as enjoying reading recent work by Lorna.

Born in Toronto, Cinders McLeod moved to Britain in 1979 and studied graphics in Somerset, art in a social context in Devon, and filmmaking in London. She wrote, sang and played doublebass in a two-woman band recorded on Billy Bragg’s label. In 1991, she moved to Scotland where she cartooned for the British Press and had two children. Her regular political cartoon strip, “Broomie Law“, was published in book form by Luath Press in 2000.

In 2001, she moved back to Canada and cartooned, animated, wrote, designed and art directed for the Globe and Mail. She is a recipient of a National Newspaper Award, a Gold Society of Newspaper Design award and a National Magazine Award finalist. In 2011, she began her daily blog, My Life as a Sketchbook: A Visual Autobiography.

Moneybunnies by Cinders McLeodWhy are there no women cartoonists? by Cinders McLeodIn 2013 she left the Globe and Mail so she could focus on her own projects: I’m A Girl! and I’m a Boy! published by HarperCollins, available as Kindle books, a video called My Life as a Political Cartoon, a novel about her Scottish-Canadian great-great-grandmother and a series of children’s financial literacy books, Moneybunnies.

On her blog, she recently highlighted some definite similarities between a cartoon she drew in 1999 for the Glasgow Herald and a silkscreen produced by Banksy, challenging him for a response.

• Cinders McLeod is online at www.cindersmcleod.com and cindersmcleod.tumblr.com and follow her on Twitter at @cindersmcleod

Published by

Avatar

John Freeman

The founder of downthetubes, John works as a comics editor, writer, as Creative Consultant on the Dan Dare audio adventures for B7 Media, and on promotional work for the Lakes International Comic Art Festival. Working in British comics publishing for over 30 years, his credits include editor of titles such as Doctor Who Magazine, Star Trek Magazine and Babylon 5 Magazine. He also edited the comics anthology STRIP Magazine and edited several audio comics for ROK Comics. He has also edited several comic collections, including volumes of “Charley’s War and “Dan Dare”. He’s the writer of “Crucible”, a creator-owned project with 2000AD artist Smuzz, published on Tapastic; and “Death Duty” and “Skow Dogs” with Dave Hailwood for digital comic 100% Biodegradable.

One thought on “WebFind: “Why Are There No Women Cartoonists?” by Cinders McLeod

  1. The item about “the lack of women cartoonists” raises a number of questions:

    1. Why are there “so few” comediennes, in contrast with comedians?

    2. Why are “comic” radio and TV panel shows male dominated?

    3. Does it matter whether a cartoon was drawn by a man or a woman (or even a transsexual)? I buy a jar of coffee because of the taste, not for the brand name.

    4. Why is who drew, painted, or wrote something considered almost more important than the result? Take the Salvator Mundi painting; is who painted it more important than the work itself? If so, why?

    After over sixty years of writing and taking photographs – and reading all manner of books, and looking at a variety of other photographers’ work – I still consider the result more important than who created it. That goes for both my and other people’s writings and photographs. I have my favourites, but – as with music – it is the individual work that matters. I have had my sales, but for me the creating comes above the selling. I do not deny that the money is welcome; as an appreciation for the time and effort spent, and publication gives enjoyment to others. But then, I never tried to make a living from selling my ‘art’.

    6. Men and women do see the world differently. In a 5 Feb 1980 broadcast of Just A Minute, Kenneth Williams said: “Intellect is not always commercial.”

    Perhaps how women see – and draw – the world is also “not always commercial”. Do men always fare better?

    7. Then there is the “women have the babies” fact that has a bearing on jobs and careers. But my mother looked after her children at the same time as running her own guest houses and hotels very successfully.

Let us know what you think about this story

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.