David Baillie reports on this year’s enormous comics extravaganza in Harrogate…


It may be difficult to believe, but at the start of the century there was usually only one comic convention per year in Britain, in pretty much the entire country. It happened in Bristol for a long time, then Brighton for a couple of years, and Birmingham for a few more. For some reason the town had to start with a B, I can’t remember what the logic was, but I do remember it seemed important at the time.
That’s why, when Thought Bubble launched back in 2007 in the basement of Leeds Town Hall, a lot of comic industry insiders frowned. Leeds? That doesn’t start with a B!
Back then, at that one comic convention per year, there would always be a panel about Small Press Comics. It would feature creators, publishers and fans making the argument that given the incredible amount of talent, creativity and determination in the British self-publishing scene this was the UK Comic Industry, not the handful of comics available from newsagents.Two decades later, those panelists have been proven right – and Thought Bubble is the proof.
Now, every year, hundreds of incredible comics creators, producing work of an astonishingly high standard, make the pilgrimage to Harrogate (again, doesn’t start with B!) to be gathered under one roof for a weekend of pure comics celebration.
At Thought Bubble, you probably don’t need me to tell you, there are comics for and by everyone. The breadth of styles, subjects and approaches on display is astonishing. There is no greater showcase for homegrown talent – no other convention on these islands can attract and offer space to 600 exhibitors, and still have a waiting list of more, every year.



Almost everyone from British comics comes to Thought Bubble most, if not every, year, including organisations and publishers. CCIC (the Comics Cultural Impact Collective) had a table, where Zara Slattery, Hannah Berry and Karrie Fransman fielded industry questions all weekend, and 2000AD, Anderson Entertainment, Avery Hill Publishing, Puffin Books, Quindrie Press, SelfMadeHero and the OK Comics and Travelling Man comic shops were all exhibiting.
Thought Bubble also offers diversity spotlight maps, helping fans find creators of colour, disabled creators and members of the LGBTQIA+ community in the (great name!) Rainbow Road Map.



I liked Thought Bubble’s original home of Leeds, but it has to be said that Harrogate itself is really, really lovely. Part of the reason it’s become such an essential part of the comics calendar is that it’s a great location to spend a wintry November weekend with comics friends.





“Thought Bubble is part Christmas party, part family reunion, and part retail kind of experience for me,” Sarah Gordon tells me, and I don’t think she’s alone in feeling like that. She’s been coming here for twenty years, since she was a student. “I guess I’m here because I like the community, more than anything else. Also people seem to really dig my work, so that also helps.”
Time Bomb Comics Steve Tanner put it like this, “It’s all about the comics. There’s a little bit of cosplay, but none of the plastic rubbish that you get everywhere else. It’s all creators and you actually get to meet the creators.”

Colleen Douglas, creator of Silk Cotton, was one of Thought Bubble’s special guests for its twentieth anniversary. She had no difficulty explaining the appeal. “It’s like coming home after you’ve been out roaming in the wild. It’s like having your nan around where they put the kettle on, and you’ve got nice cakes. Everybody’s so shut in working, this is all about the comics. And it’s pure love. That’s why I come.”

Gustaffo Vargas is a master craftsman specialising in Peruvian cyberpunk comics, who’s recently branched out into drawing Power Rangers for BOOM! Studios. “Why I love Thought Bubble, it’s because you have everything here. You have professionals, newbies, and all the varieties and all the different people making comics that they care for. Just people trying to find new ways of telling stories, everyone in the same room and there’s something for anyone.”
That variety is something Russell Mark Olsen, promoting the new Deluxe Edition of The Phantom (in comic shops next month) as well as the third volume of fabulous comics magazine Scrawl (which also features Gustaffo) was particularly enthusiastic about. “You get to see this amazing amount of comics – of wonderful, creative comics from every single walk of life. I love how inclusive it is. It just feels like this lovely sort of warm place where anyone and everyone is welcome. There are books that relate to people’s lives, there are books that allow people to escape their lives. And from table to table, the absolute overwhelming pride is amazing.
“Also, what I love about the UK comics scene, and I think it’s celebrated most in this festival, is just how much support there is amongst comics creators for other comics creators. In this country people help each other up the ladder, it’s wonderful.”
That’s an excellent description of the atmosphere. It’s not simply a place where people sell their own work; there’s a genuine enthusiasm for what everyone else is doing, too.

This is the sixth Thought Bubble for Nigel Twumasi, co-founder of manga brand Mayamada, who also singled out this co-operative spirit as something that appeals to him. “It’s rare, or at least, it’s not as usual to see a hall full of independent comic makers, without very large brands taking up a lot of the oxygen. I always appreciate that at Thought Bubble, so that’s the reason why I keep coming back.”
The weekend has plenty to offer fans beyond the exhibition halls, with panels covering everything from Advice for Aspiring Children’s Comic Creators to a roundtable panel on Fair Pay and Economic Justice, and of course an hour celebrating 20 Years of Thought Bubble.


I thikn my favourite panel was a brilliant session where Tana Ford, Jahnoy Lindsay and Dan McDaid sketched superheroes while their their work was projected onto a large screen and they chatted to host Kofi Smiles. I particularly enjoyed hearing McDaid explain why drawing villains is way more fun, while depicting a very funky Hulk.

Another panel I really enjoyed was the Waifs and Strays spotlight, which saw Sarah L. Miles talk to a bunch of new writers and artists who had used the deadlines of Thought Bubble and its various talent searches to generate enough work to fill multiple anthology collections. “You could be sitting here next year,” one creator assured an audience of eager hopefuls.
The talent searches were immensely hot tickets, as always. 2000AD‘s portfolio review line had to be capped very early, and the writers’ pitchfest is so popular that it’s had to employ a lottery system for the last few years. Alison Sampson curated another great round of portfolio reviews, in which prospective artists didn’t know which of the professionals they would be seen by, helping to avoid the stylistic tunnel vision that can sometimes develop early in a creator’s journey.
Every year I meet creators who first came to Thought Bubble as fans, and are now working on their own projects, exhibiting and publishing. It’s also a great place to find independent publishers to work with and get your stuff out there. “I look for new talent here. People that we might use in future books to do illustrations and artwork,” the Eagle Award-winning writer and publisher Dave West told me.

Among those many independent creators was Sam Hart, who was launching his graphic novel, 10 Lost Days: The End of Magic at Thought Bubble, a 186-page adventure published by Scratch Comics, based on historical fact – which is at the end of the 16th century, ten days were skipped at the change from the Julian to the Gregorian calendar. “In those ten days, I’ve inserted an adventure where Tycho Brahe’s sister, Sophia, has to save the world against a terrible threat,” he tells me.
There was plenty for younger visitors, too, with a kids’ zone providing a dedicated, specially designed space with desks, paper and pens where they could sit down and get creative. The workshop area was busy for every session and it was great to see excited young creatives enjoying sessions aimed at them, like Abby Bulmer‘s amazing guide to Drawing Hilarious Doggo Comics and Candice Whatmore‘s high-energy Puzzle Slug workshop.

If all of this sounds lovely but potentially overwhelming, it absolutely is – which is one reason the Graphic Novel Reading Room has become one of my favourite regular hang-out spots. “GRRR is a one-man band,” founder Gabi Putnoki told me. “Thought Bubble approached me, but I wanted to come anyway! It’s just the perfect marriage of having a really bustling downstairs, with lots of stimulation, and then having an upstairs where people can just chill out and read books.
There’s plenty of work from all corners of the comics medium in the GRRR, but Gabi’s especially happy about having a selection of work by current exhibitors. “I have a section where I display the artists who are at the festival, so people can sample their work in advance and get to know them. If they like it, they can just go to the artist straight away. So, trying to reduce that kind of awkward standing-in-front-of-the-table interaction as well. It’s another quiet space, and you also get to sample lots of comics – so it’s a marriage made in heaven!”
Of all the UK conventions, Thought Bubble is the one that many North Americans mention first – and hope to be invited to! This year was no exception, with Jeffrey Brown, Becky Cloonan, Tana Ford and Kate Beaton in attendance, rubbing shoulders with huge UK comics names like Tula Lotay, Jock, The Etherington Brothers and Alice Oseman.
The reason they’ve heard of Thought Bubble across the pond is its reputation as Party Central, and this year was no exception. It all started with the now-regular welcome event at the fabulous Mercer Gallery, which kicks off every TB weekend and allows attendees to pick up wristbands and avoid the legendary Saturday morning queue, while taking in the gallery’s excellent collection!

Paul Cornell and Lee Harris’ new graphic novel company, Cosmic Lighthouse, hosted a launch party at the Everyman Cinema bar, upstairs from the fab Destination Venus comics shop. Then there was the Twentieth Anniversary Phonogram Party, which saw a host of comic creators take to the DJ decks. The mid-con party at Mojo’s may have been a little quieter than usual, but that was actually a welcome development for anyone who’d struggled to find dance floor space in previous years.
And I couldn’t wrap up this vignette of a review without mentioning the legendary Red Shirts, the volunteers who keep Thought Bubble running smoothly. I spoke to one, Stuart Hume, who helped me navigate my way to a meeting I should have set off five minutes earlier for. “This is my third year, so I’m still a rookie. I’ve just come through my probation now,” he joked.

I asked him what’s so special about Thought Bubble that he’d decided to volunteer?
“It’s just absolutely lovely. First of all, the volunteers, it’s like one big family. But the organisers, too, there’s no sort of hierarchy. Everyone’s just fantastic. The building as well, fantastic security, even the parking guys. Then you get people like us: we take days off work, we spend money on hotels, we spend a stupid amount of money on books when we’re here, to work for three, four hard, long days. Not for money, but because it’s just worth it. It’s fantastic!”
And as I run for my train (I was consistently five minutes late across the whole weekend, as anyone I promised to meet will attest) all I can think about is how much I agree with Red Shirt Stuart. It really is lovely.
David Baillie
David Baillie writes comics and can be found online at davidbaillie.net
• Thought Bubble is online at thoughtbubblefestival.com
Further Thoughts on Thought Bubble
My apologies to those who provided soundbites that ended up being inaudible due to the general excitement and chaos of Thought Bubble (compliment)

“I think the thing with Thought Bubble is that the diversity of the creativity here is astounding. You’ve got six hundred different publishers, vastly different sizes and ambitions, but the one unifying factor is they just want to tell stories in comic book form. And it’s a true comic book festival. I think it’s the only one of its kind in the country that you can truly say it’s all about comics.
“We’ve probably had the best weekend we’ve ever had at a comics show. We’ve got with us Dan Dare, Hancock, Pilgrim, and lots of other work as well. There’s been a steady flow of interest.”
“The thing is you sort of work in a bit of a bubble sometimes, and what’s been reassuring and lovely is people who have bought our comics, be it Pilgrim, or Mr Jones’ Smoking Bones, Hancock or they’ve backed Dan Dare, and they’ve come over and said lovely things.”
Andrew Mark Sewell and Helen Quigley at B7 Media

“We love coming to Thought Bubble because it’s full of a really diverse crowd, young creators telling autobiographical stories, very few capes, very friendly – and it’s in Yorkshire, so it should be really friendly.”
“I agree with everything Will said. Everybody should be buying Geezer. It’s our baby, and we love it, and we’d love people to see it.”
Will Potter and Philip Bond, who were on the Off Register stand, flogging Geezer and Shelly Bond’s beautiful books on editing

“Thought Bubble is an amazing event that presents all kinds of opportunity to all different types of people engaged in the comics community. It’s been going for 20 years now. I’ve been to most of them and I’ve enjoyed every one of them. And they’ve always been a very successful, financially rewarding event. Long live Thought Bubble!”
Sean Azzopardi, publisher of PhatComics

“I love Thought Bubble because it’s the most comics-focused festival in the UK. It’s always a lot of fun to catch up with all my friends, like Rob Williams and David Baillie, to name a couple. And it’s always got a positive, positive energy, always a lot of fun!”
“I love Thought Bubble. Basically it’s a celebration of comics, and a lot of other shows aren’t. When you walk around, there’s an amazing amount of good work from people you’ve never heard of. So it kind of makes you feel that there is a future in comics, when the rest of the time all the evidence isn’t necessarily in agreement.”
David Baillie writes comics and can be found online at davidbaillie.net
• Thought Bubble is online at thoughtbubblefestival.com
Where possible, book links in this article are affiliates for Gosh! Comics reflecting the independent nature of Thought Bubble. All photos by David Baillie unless otherwise stated
Categories: 2000AD, British Comics, Comics, Creating Comics, downthetubes Comics News, downthetubes News, Events, Features, Reviews
Leave a Reply