Why WHSmith redundancies and further store closures are bad news for British comics

WHSmith Logo

Leading high street news vendor WHSmith, which also operates stores at airports and rail stations, has announced a number of store closures and redundancies of 1500, responding to trading losses resulting from the Coronavirus Pandemic.

Initial indications are that 14 stores will close, possibly mainly those run as part of its separate division servicing airports and rail stations. None have been named as redundancy discussions have yet to take place, but many local newspapers inaccurately projected possible closure of local WHS reporting the story, which is why I have taken the unusual step of run the full WHSmith Trading Update, below.

The only bright side to this news is that WHSmith says it expects to weather the storm, although not, obviously, without cost.

Whatever we may think of WHSmithand I’ve been critical of the company in the past, particularly about its ridiculous decision to compact its Unique Selling Point comics, magazine and newspaper section in favour of of non USP chocolates, pens and other items – the fact is that for many, their separate divisions still provide a vital gateway and discovery point for the comics and magazines.

When it’s hit by economic circumstance caused, in this instance by Covid-19, WHSmith may sneeze (forgive the analogy), but the publishing industry will very definitely catch a cold.

The kids comics section for WHSmith in Lancaster seems to have been squeezed ever smaller in favour of other magazines. (Teen-targeted titles like 2000AD, Commando and others are racked separately in this and other WHS stores)
The kids comics section for WHSmith in Lancaster earlier this year (Teen-targeted titles like 2000AD, Commando and others are racked separately in this and other WHS stores)
Panini and Titan Comics "digest" titles, collecting DC and Marvel comic strips, are poorly displayed
Some of the wide range of specialist titles stocked in WHSmith

Easons has already gone in Northern Ireland, which will severely damage comic sales and specialist magazine sales there. Some publishers such as PaniniUK, have already delayed releases of some titles in response to reduced distribution points during lockdown. And while Beano sales are almost 50 per cent subscription, and the title has a good supermarket presence, WHSmith woes will not help it. Who knows what this will mean for 2000AD, or Commando, which do not report newsstand sales figure publicly.

The WHSmith announcement is not a surprise but it is very bad news for a publishing industry still trying to gain momentum in terms of direct online sales, which are still in percentage terms much lower than brick and mortar sales; and still early into restructuring to boost subscription and ancillary online offerings.

WHSmith Trading Update: Press Release in Full

Source

Further to the update issued on 14 May 2020, and as a result of the evolving situation regarding Covid-19, WH Smith PLC is today issuing a trading update. In addition, the Group sets out its proposed plans to restructure its UK store operations.

WH Smith Group Chief Executive, Carl Cowling, commented:
“Covid-19 continues to have a significant impact on the WH Smith Group. Throughout the pandemic, we have responded quickly and taken decisive actions to protect the business including substantially strengthening our financial position. We have also welcomed support from Government where available.

“In our Travel business, while we are beginning to see early signs of recovery in some of our markets, the speed of recovery continues to be slow. At the same time, while there has been some progress in our High Street business, it does continue to be adversely affected by low levels of footfall. As a result, we now need to take further action to reduce costs across our businesses. I regret that this will have an impact on a significant number of colleagues whose roles will be affected by these necessary actions, and we will do everything we can to support them at this challenging time.

“While we are mindful of the continuing uncertainties that exist, we are a resilient and versatile business. The operational actions we are taking along with the financing arrangements that are in place, put us in a strong position to navigate this time of uncertainty and we are well positioned to benefit in due course from the recovery of our key markets.”

Trading Update

At our trading update on 6 April 2020 we indicated that we assumed that Group total revenue would be down between 80% and 85% from April until 31 August 2020 against the same period in the previous year. As lockdown restrictions have eased around the world, we have seen a gradual recovery although sales continue to be materially down versus the prior year.

WHSmith - 2020 Trading Projections
WHSmith – 2020 Trading Projections

In Travel, although passenger numbers remain significantly down year on year, we have begun a phased reopening of our UK stores across our air and rail channels. We are now trading in 246 of our largest stores which have historically represented c.75% of annual revenue. We now have 53% of our UK Travel store estate open and we remain focused on increasing average transaction value in these locations.


In the US, where approximately 85% of passengers are domestic, we anticipate a faster recovery versus the rest of the world. Overall revenue is down 80%, although we have seen an encouraging performance from the 147 stores that we have reopened to date with sales in these stores down c.50%. During the second half, we accelerated the integration of the InMotion head office into MRG. We are pleased with the progress we have made and we are on target to have this completed by the end of the year.

Outside of the UK and the US, we are seeing broadly similar trends to UK air with passenger numbers significantly down year on year and an increase in average transaction value. We now have 153 stores open across the rest of the world.

In High Street, our 203 stores that host Post Offices remained open through the pandemic to provide vital postal and banking services to their local communities. Given we kept stores open in these locations, we were well advanced with our reopening plans for the stores that had temporarily closed. Since June, we have reopened our remaining High Street stores with 575 now open, though high street footfall is significantly down on 2019 levels. Our online businesses have continued to perform strongly.

As a result of the impact on passenger numbers and lower footfall on the UK high street, we have taken the difficult decision to review our store operations across both our Travel and High Street businesses. We are now starting a collective consultation on a proposed restructure which could lead to up to c.1,500 roles becoming redundant. This has been a very difficult decision and we are committed to supporting all our colleagues throughout this process and ensuring it is conducted fairly.

Based on our initial assessment, we believe that the costs associated with the restructure will be in the region of £15m – £19m (monthly recurring cash burn before any cost deferrals or one-off savings/costs.), reflecting the Group’s enhanced redundancy policy.

Following the impact of Covid-19 in the second half of the financial year, the Group expects to deliver a headline loss before tax for the financial year ending 31 August 2020 of between £70m and £75m.

Liquidity Position

Our liquidity position remains consistent with the detail we provided at our Interim results on 14 May 2020. As at 4 August, we had cash of approximately £63m with a revolving credit facility of £200m and an additional committed bank facility of £120m, both of which are undrawn. In addition, we have secured eligibility for the Government’s Covid Corporate Financing Facility (‘CCFF’). In July, our monthly cash burn on an underlying trading basis was between £15m and £20m, which includes costs associated with previously announced Head Office restructure on 1 July 2020.

The £120m short term facility, which was agreed at the time of the Group’s refinancing in April, was due to be cancelled when the Group accessed the CCFF. We have now agreed an amendment to this short term facility with our banks so that there is no immediate requirement to cancel the short term facility, should we access the CCFF.

Taking into account the Group’s current financing arrangements, combined with a variety of operational actions, the Board is confident that the Group has sufficient funds to allow it to operate throughout a prolonged downturn in our markets.

Preliminary Announcement

WH Smith PLC will announce its 2020 Preliminary results on Thursday 12 November 2020.

Avatar

The founder of downthetubes, John works as a comics editor, writer, as Creative Consultant on the Dan Dare audio adventures for B7 Media, and on promotional work for the Lakes International Comic Art Festival. Working in British comics publishing for over 30 years, his credits include editor of titles such as Doctor Who Magazine, Star Trek Magazine and Babylon 5 Magazine. He also edited the comics anthology STRIP Magazine and edited several audio comics for ROK Comics. He has also edited several comic collections, including volumes of “Charley’s War and “Dan Dare”. He’s the writer of “Crucible”, a creator-owned project with 2000AD artist Smuzz, published on Tapastic; and “Death Duty” and “Skow Dogs” with Dave Hailwood for digital comic 100% Biodegradable.



Categories: British Comics, downthetubes Comics News, downthetubes News, Features, Opinions

Tags: , , ,

3 replies

  1. The problem for bookstores is that the market has shrunk, primarily do to eReaders. I kniow my wife prefers an eReader and if she buys a book it is the electronic edition.rather than a physical book. That is why so many of the larger booksellers now carry a lot of non-book products. They sell, sell well, probably have higher margins and thus help the stores stay open

    • Good points, but at the end of the day, a pen or pack of envelopes has a much longer shelf life than a daily newspaper, weekly comic or monthly magazine, so why limit the opportunity to sell such items – the very reason most people walk into WHSmith – by cramping publications up and making them hard to find – in some cases even harder by hiding them behind the counter, on the basis of alleged regular theft of some items?

  2. I guess I am a bit luckier then. Our local chapters keeps the periodicals they carry on the stands until the next issue is out. They are also to the side of the entrance, and visible from the sidewalk outside the store. The only thing kept behind the counter are the freebies that come attached to the magazines, such as CDs Admittedly Chapters doesn’t carry a lot of comics, most Archie, but that is due to most people preferring to go to the comic store in town for their fix. For legal reasons we don’t have W.H. Smith in Canada, though at one time we did.

%d bloggers like this: